Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to death
Moderators: DJKeefy, 4u Network
- DJKeefy
- Site Administrator
- Posts: 11025
- Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2005 4:08 pm
- Location: UK
- Has thanked: 652 times
- Been thanked: 1222 times
- Gender:
- Contact:
Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to death
Egypt's Minya criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to death.
In a historical first in Egypt, a Minya Court has ordered that 529 Muslim Brotherhood supporters be sentenced to death for involvement in 'violence' following #Morsi's ouster and the dispersal of Rabaa Al-Adaweya.
According to initial reports, 529 were sentenced to death and 17 found innocent on charges of attacking police stations, killing police officers, and other violence-related charges.
The paperwork to finalize the death sentences, the largest ever in one case a number greater than the total number sentenced to death in Egypt's modern history, will now be sent to the Grand Mufti for approval. Normally such a procedure is purely procedural, but it remains to be seem whether this week be an exceptional case requiring action to stop.
In a historical first in Egypt, a Minya Court has ordered that 529 Muslim Brotherhood supporters be sentenced to death for involvement in 'violence' following #Morsi's ouster and the dispersal of Rabaa Al-Adaweya.
According to initial reports, 529 were sentenced to death and 17 found innocent on charges of attacking police stations, killing police officers, and other violence-related charges.
The paperwork to finalize the death sentences, the largest ever in one case a number greater than the total number sentenced to death in Egypt's modern history, will now be sent to the Grand Mufti for approval. Normally such a procedure is purely procedural, but it remains to be seem whether this week be an exceptional case requiring action to stop.
-
- Egyptian Pharaoh
- Posts: 4154
- Joined: Wed Jul 29, 2009 10:04 pm
- Location: London
- Has thanked: 905 times
- Been thanked: 1113 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
I am not quite clear how the court proceeding were carried out, is it possible that a member of the forum in Egypt could enlighten us, as to whether each case was carried out to the standards of international law.
- Glyphdoctor
- Egyptian God
- Posts: 7525
- Joined: Mon Aug 08, 2005 2:48 pm
- Has thanked: 332 times
- Been thanked: 1015 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
http://english.ahram.org.eg/NewsContent ... --Bro.aspx
http://thecairopost.com/news/103433/new ... -acquitted
These links might help to explain some more. I also believe, but am not certain, that those tried in absentia do not have the right of appeal.
http://thecairopost.com/news/103433/new ... -acquitted
These links might help to explain some more. I also believe, but am not certain, that those tried in absentia do not have the right of appeal.
- Who2
- Egyptian God
- Posts: 7912
- Joined: Fri Jul 16, 2010 12:04 pm
- Location: Laandaan
- Has thanked: 1114 times
- Been thanked: 3214 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
Far be it from me, but it sounds a little bit OTT, not sure how the world's media will view it, but no-doubt will make for great television..
"The Salvation of Mankind lies in making everything the responsibility of All"
Sophocles.
Sophocles.
- Chocolate Eclair
- Royal V.I.P
- Posts: 1621
- Joined: Sun Aug 22, 2010 4:56 pm
- Location: Luxor Egypt
- Has thanked: 37 times
- Been thanked: 300 times
- Gender:
- Contact:
- Brian Yare
- Royal V.I.P
- Posts: 2566
- Joined: Mon Dec 01, 2008 4:11 pm
- Location: Worcester, UK
- Has thanked: 720 times
- Been thanked: 647 times
- Gender:
- Contact:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
Why International law? Egypt has its own laws and can apply them as it wishes.A-Four wrote:I am not quite clear how the court proceeding were carried out, is it possible that a member of the forum in Egypt could enlighten us, as to whether each case was carried out to the standards of international law.
It will be interesting to see how the Grand Mufti treats his brethren.
-
- Egyptian Pharaoh
- Posts: 4154
- Joined: Wed Jul 29, 2009 10:04 pm
- Location: London
- Has thanked: 905 times
- Been thanked: 1113 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
This morning here in London we learn that Mohammed Badie along with 682 others go on trial today, at the same court where yesterday 540 were sentenced to death.
.........oh what a circus, oh what a show,...........
.........oh what a circus, oh what a show,...........
-
- Member
- Posts: 111
- Joined: Mon Jan 30, 2012 10:18 pm
- Location: UK
- Has thanked: 48 times
- Been thanked: 98 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
On BBC news last night - one of the "condemned"was interviewed in Cairo - currently on bail he was tried I believe "in abstentia" claiming the defence presented + 1000 pages of evidence which was not heard in a case which lasted less than one day before sentence was passed.
As I understand, during the index demonstrations, a police officer lost his life and I agree that those responsible should be brought to justice.
But there is no justice in putting to death 540 people.
All actions in life have an underlying motivation/intent - and it is clear that the intent here is not one of achieving justice.
OK this is Egypt not Britain - but the founding principle of British law is "He that seek equity do equity".
Our world is a small one, and if we continue to close our eyes to global crimes against humanity we cannot expect ad infinitum that our own principles of justice will continue to hold up, inside our very small castle walls.
For those of you who chose to make your homes and lives in Egypt - agreeably you have your day to day challenges - and you are not Egyptian - but it is your adopted home.
If the Egyptian courts carry out these sentences - what do you feel that will do to the national conscience of Egyptians - people you live amongst, live with, trade with, socialise with?
Do you want to continue to live in a country that will effectively murder 540 of its own with no underlying justifiable cause?
Do you feel this is a situation where you need to speak out?
Just interested to hear what the ex-pat community feels on this issue?
S x
As I understand, during the index demonstrations, a police officer lost his life and I agree that those responsible should be brought to justice.
But there is no justice in putting to death 540 people.
All actions in life have an underlying motivation/intent - and it is clear that the intent here is not one of achieving justice.
OK this is Egypt not Britain - but the founding principle of British law is "He that seek equity do equity".
Our world is a small one, and if we continue to close our eyes to global crimes against humanity we cannot expect ad infinitum that our own principles of justice will continue to hold up, inside our very small castle walls.
For those of you who chose to make your homes and lives in Egypt - agreeably you have your day to day challenges - and you are not Egyptian - but it is your adopted home.
If the Egyptian courts carry out these sentences - what do you feel that will do to the national conscience of Egyptians - people you live amongst, live with, trade with, socialise with?
Do you want to continue to live in a country that will effectively murder 540 of its own with no underlying justifiable cause?
Do you feel this is a situation where you need to speak out?
Just interested to hear what the ex-pat community feels on this issue?
S x
- Chocolate Eclair
- Royal V.I.P
- Posts: 1621
- Joined: Sun Aug 22, 2010 4:56 pm
- Location: Luxor Egypt
- Has thanked: 37 times
- Been thanked: 300 times
- Gender:
- Contact:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
Wonder if these people still live in Egypt? and how many were sentenced in their absence. I know it seems harsh, but the Country has its laws, and they must be obeyed whoever you are. Also to pass such sentences there must be a lot of substantial evidence to prove their guilt.
- Glyphdoctor
- Egyptian God
- Posts: 7525
- Joined: Mon Aug 08, 2005 2:48 pm
- Has thanked: 332 times
- Been thanked: 1015 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
I'm tempted to set up an anonymous Survey Monkey survey with one question:
"What do you really think about what is going on in Egypt these days?"
And then invite all L4U members to weigh in and see what you all really think.
It definitely would be enlightening, more enlightening probably than anything posted here.
"What do you really think about what is going on in Egypt these days?"
And then invite all L4U members to weigh in and see what you all really think.
It definitely would be enlightening, more enlightening probably than anything posted here.
-
- Member
- Posts: 111
- Joined: Mon Jan 30, 2012 10:18 pm
- Location: UK
- Has thanked: 48 times
- Been thanked: 98 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
Im not the brightest bean in the box so happy to stand corrected as needed - howeverChocolate Eclair wrote:Wonder if these people still live in Egypt? and how many were sentenced in their absence. I know it seems harsh, but the Country has its laws, and they must be obeyed whoever you are. Also to pass such sentences there must be a lot of substantial evidence to prove their guilt.
Laws - what is "fair" law - something that has stood in tradition - or something that is made up as we go along to suit the political needs of the moment.
Substantial evidence - the "trial" lasted one session - I am not sure what opportunity that gave either the prosecution or defence a chance to fairly present the arguments.
The country has its laws - that is as maybe - but that doesn't make them right or fair. And in a country trying to find a pathway to sustainable democracy, this type of act takes it right back to the dark ages of dictatorship - with a population cowed by fear.
The law must be obeyed whoever you are - tell me honestly - In all you do, do you always obey Egyptian law to the letter?
Or are the "Colonials" exempt from that?
And does the "law" only apply to those who in their view challenged the overthrowing of what they saw as their democratically elected leader?
I get the argument that we have no right to intervene in the politics of other countries - and we do do far too much of it. BUT as individual human beings - what of our own salvation when we stand back and say nothing..
Sx
- carrie
- Egyptian Pharaoh
- Posts: 4910
- Joined: Mon Mar 14, 2005 10:46 am
- Location: luxor
- Has thanked: 1860 times
- Been thanked: 2885 times
- Contact:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
Well I will take your survey Glyph and say I don't know what is going on, how 500+ people can be fairly judged in two short sessions in the court amazes me and today another 600+ go on trial.
I have no idea what the future of Egypt will be but believe me I wouldn't have the job of President here for a Kings ransom, who ever gets the job and it looks more and more likely to be Field Marshall El Sisi, I don't envy him. Not being sexist by saying him but NO chance for a woman.
I have no idea what the future of Egypt will be but believe me I wouldn't have the job of President here for a Kings ransom, who ever gets the job and it looks more and more likely to be Field Marshall El Sisi, I don't envy him. Not being sexist by saying him but NO chance for a woman.
- Dusak
- Egyptian Pharaoh
- Posts: 6190
- Joined: Sun May 11, 2008 2:29 pm
- Location: LUXOR
- Has thanked: 3241 times
- Been thanked: 3812 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
When a country like Egypt has its courts and prisons and dark undisclosed pens full to bursting with what this country has now labeled 'terrorists' they probably feel they have the right to fast track them to the gallows. Could you ever believe or trust a terrorist? Is it not better, in the grand schema of things, to cleanse the nation of these folk that not to long ago they, the people, were hailing as the savior's of a dieing country. This land is fickle to the point of not knowing which way to turn, who to support and change their views on everything on a daily basis. The pathway is long and the population is easily lead in the one direction. Offer them the moon they will except, the only questions asked when do we get it? And will it bring down the price of cheese? If you suddenly give a child a toy to play with and that child has never seen a toy before he/she will probable ruin it before they discover its true worth.
I comment to friends about the state of things as they are now, or could be tomorrow. But for me, leave the politics of a foreign country to the gifted politicians. We all just have to wait that little bit longer until some show up that would warrant that title.
I comment to friends about the state of things as they are now, or could be tomorrow. But for me, leave the politics of a foreign country to the gifted politicians. We all just have to wait that little bit longer until some show up that would warrant that title.
Life is your's to do with as you wish- do not let other's try to control it for you. Count Dusak- 1345.
-
- Egyptian Pharaoh
- Posts: 4154
- Joined: Wed Jul 29, 2009 10:04 pm
- Location: London
- Has thanked: 905 times
- Been thanked: 1113 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
Ah, but Glyph, you know as well as I, that there would be two schools of thought, those that write from an Egyptian dongal, and those that do not.Glyphdoctor wrote:I'm tempted to set up an anonymous Survey Monkey survey with one question:
"What do you really think about what is going on in Egypt these days?"
And then invite all L4U members to weigh in and see what you all really think.
It definitely would be enlightening, more enlightening probably than anything posted here.
This could be the start of the 'reign of terror', remember there are still some 16,000 still in jail since the fall of Morsi, awaiting trial, many on trumped up charges.
-
- Egyptian Pharaoh
- Posts: 4154
- Joined: Wed Jul 29, 2009 10:04 pm
- Location: London
- Has thanked: 905 times
- Been thanked: 1113 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
A couple of weeks ago now, during the Mousi trial, it was 'discovered' that his annual salary was set at £44,000, however we learn that he In fact claimed £77,000. A difference of £33,000. This shows how crazy proceeding are carried out, the court was outraged that he had 'taken' this additional amount.
For goodness sake, British M.P.'s fiddle more than that on their allowances, whether it be a garden bird bath or what. We are talking of a president of a nation, he could not just get on the Cairo metro and pay l LE, like other people.
The trial continues,................and so will the comedy.
For goodness sake, British M.P.'s fiddle more than that on their allowances, whether it be a garden bird bath or what. We are talking of a president of a nation, he could not just get on the Cairo metro and pay l LE, like other people.
The trial continues,................and so will the comedy.
Last edited by A-Four on Tue Mar 25, 2014 4:08 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Member
- Posts: 111
- Joined: Mon Jan 30, 2012 10:18 pm
- Location: UK
- Has thanked: 48 times
- Been thanked: 98 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
Dusak wrote:When a country like Egypt has its courts and prisons and dark undisclosed pens full to bursting with what this country has now labeled 'terrorists' they probably feel they have the right to fast track them to the gallows. Could you ever believe or trust a terrorist? Is it not better, in the grand schema of things, to cleanse the nation of these folk that not to long ago they, the people, were hailing as the savior's of a dieing country. This land is fickle to the point of not knowing which way to turn, who to support and change their views on everything on a daily basis. The pathway is long and the population is easily lead in the one direction. Offer them the moon they will except, the only questions asked when do we get it? And will it bring down the price of cheese? If you suddenly give a child a toy to play with and that child has never seen a toy before he/she will probable ruin it before they discover its true worth.
I comment to friends about the state of things as they are now, or could be tomorrow. But for me, leave the politics of a foreign country to the gifted politicians. We all just have to wait that little bit longer until some show up that would warrant that title.
Without meaning to sound "Colonialist" -
I remember when McDonald's first opened in Luxor - I thought this is great - let the kids run round with no shoes on their feet but hey ho at least they can eat burgers!
Then of course came the "Shirley Valentines" …I remember one night sitting in a Luxor restaurant with a couple - she british in her late 50's, dripping gold and cleavage, he barely 16 in pink flip flops sporting a Rolex.
My own feeling was that Egypt, particularly Luxor at that time, was growing like some deformed creature - 10 foot arms but no legs to support itself on.
I chastised myself for being "colonialist" - why shouldn't Egyptian children eat McDonalds if those in Blighty can - and the answer to myself was, that despite all the shortcomings, in Blighty before we had what can be described as mass consumer "wealth" we had a functioning health service, compulsory education, almost full employment, a welfare state, nationalised utilities - Egypt had none of those things in place to a functional national/equitable standard.
I remember watching the "revolution" and commenting to my partner - "the trouble with Egyptians is that they know what they don't want, but they don't know what they really do want and within that no understanding of what it is possible to have and certainly not in the timeframe they wish to have it".
No wonder they are "fickle" - the "snapshots" of Western consumerism that the young men particularly, have been able to access in recent years have "spoilt" a generation and possibly cost the best chance that Egypt ever had to move to a democratic society.
I feel sad that so many lives are now condemned and I do think that a lot of what is going wrong it directly linked to the influence of "western" culture in small towns like Luxor
Sx
- Glyphdoctor
- Egyptian God
- Posts: 7525
- Joined: Mon Aug 08, 2005 2:48 pm
- Has thanked: 332 times
- Been thanked: 1015 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
During Morsi's rule, at least half of the metro passengers got on and off the trains without buying tickets at all. G4S was providing the security...or not.A-Four wrote:We are talking of a president of a nation, he could not just get on the Cairo metro and pay l LE, like other people.
Then a few weeks after he was removed, G4S was no longer providing security. Instead Queen Service started providing security and people started buying tickets again. I'll let you do your own research on who owns Queen.
-
- Egyptian Pharaoh
- Posts: 4154
- Joined: Wed Jul 29, 2009 10:04 pm
- Location: London
- Has thanked: 905 times
- Been thanked: 1113 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
Glyphdoctor wrote:During Morsi's rule, at least half of the metro passengers got on and off the trains without buying tickets at all. G4S was providing the security...or not.A-Four wrote:We are talking of a president of a nation, he could not just get on the Cairo metro and pay l LE, like other people.
Then a few weeks after he was removed, G4S was no longer providing security. Instead Queen Service started providing security and people started buying tickets again. I'll let you do your own research on who owns Queen.
Not only will the military in Egypt be getting 100% of the vote, but it seems that their present 40% of Egypt's GDP hold on the economy will soon reach that same dizzy height. .
- Dusak
- Egyptian Pharaoh
- Posts: 6190
- Joined: Sun May 11, 2008 2:29 pm
- Location: LUXOR
- Has thanked: 3241 times
- Been thanked: 3812 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
They are always spouting on about what they are giving the people on the local Arabic TV channels. But they never mention the fact that this ''new'' revenue has come from the hundreds of thousands of pensions they have cut or removed from the people that need it the most, the impoverished. Now they are on about cutting the subsidized monthly food boxes to only those that really need it, the dead probably when they have died of starvation. ? Box of food or a box of bullets? Decisions, decisions.
Life is your's to do with as you wish- do not let other's try to control it for you. Count Dusak- 1345.
- Hafiz
- V.I.P
- Posts: 1284
- Joined: Mon Feb 20, 2012 4:23 pm
- Has thanked: 614 times
- Been thanked: 632 times
- Gender:
Re: Criminal court sentences 529 Brotherhood supporters to d
The bluster about colonialism is just that. Its for Egypt to set and determine crimes but the issue in the west is not the penalty but due process and I encourage others to read the eye witness new agency reports on the comedic Kafka court proceedings that led to the 529 death penalties for 1 murder and a small number of other crimes.
As a aside consider, from a logical point of view, of how 529 persons could be convicted of a single murder. Did they all conspire and agree this at a single or multiple meetings? If so the meeting must have been large and the attendance list well kept. With such a large group how could all be so equally liable? Surely some were more liable than others? The offenses involved are starting to sound like group guilt where each individual member of a particular group is equally responsible for all the actions of all other members of the group whether they actually participated in the actions of the group or whether they protested or argued against them. I suspect that the brotherhood statutes are drafted in this way and that no actual involvement in any one crime is necessary in order to execute any member of the Brotherhood whether he lives at the other end of Egypt or opposes violence or not.
Don't forget the charge was for only one murder. For due process the individual accused must know what they are charged with, the state must give evidence proving guilt which can be cross-examined, the accused must be allowed to produce evidence of innicence, there must be rules of evidence, the judge must be independent, the accused must be allowed counsel etc. None of this has happened but it wouldn't have been too difficult for the Government to do this. Had the government provided for procedural fairness the UN would have had little to complain of. Another way of looking at it is that no judicial system worth its salt charges and convicts a group. Each person must be shown that he/she was individually responsible for the crime.
No judge in any civilized country would handle a capital crime in such a summary and bulk justice way but judges in Egypt have, over the past 3 years, been prepared to proceed in an unjudicial and pro-government way in the Mubarak cases, including others charged of financial crimes, and, more recently the lenient penalties, 7 years, for police murder of 37 protesters.
There is mounting evidence that the Egyptian Judiciary is an arm of government just as it was for decades under Sadat and Mubarak but what is new is that it thinks it can get away with scandalous breaches of due process. In the 'good old days' they would have run the case for a few months and acquitted the young and very old and the west would have said little.
In this case several hours of court hearings have been considered sufficient for 529 death sentences. Life is obviously cheap and guilt is universally uniform across this very large group.
In another case, which includes the Australian journalist, western reporters allege that the state case was not ready and that the judge had to assist state 'witnesses' because the whole case was badly investigated and presented in court. Quick and dirty court proceedings like the case of the 529 have the effect of concealing the weakness of the state case just and even with very prominent cases, such as the Jazeera Australian case, there is a shamelessness about lack of evidence and intervention by the judge to assist the state case. If they can't develop a case in this one then god knows what cases they bring to court in less prominent ones.
The Government are moving to deal with the overwhelming negative international reaction and one release emphasizes that the convictions were made by a junior and provincial court and that there was a right of appeal. Expect a suitably lengthy appear and 20% acquittals or non-capital convictions to make it look like there has been
As a aside consider, from a logical point of view, of how 529 persons could be convicted of a single murder. Did they all conspire and agree this at a single or multiple meetings? If so the meeting must have been large and the attendance list well kept. With such a large group how could all be so equally liable? Surely some were more liable than others? The offenses involved are starting to sound like group guilt where each individual member of a particular group is equally responsible for all the actions of all other members of the group whether they actually participated in the actions of the group or whether they protested or argued against them. I suspect that the brotherhood statutes are drafted in this way and that no actual involvement in any one crime is necessary in order to execute any member of the Brotherhood whether he lives at the other end of Egypt or opposes violence or not.
Don't forget the charge was for only one murder. For due process the individual accused must know what they are charged with, the state must give evidence proving guilt which can be cross-examined, the accused must be allowed to produce evidence of innicence, there must be rules of evidence, the judge must be independent, the accused must be allowed counsel etc. None of this has happened but it wouldn't have been too difficult for the Government to do this. Had the government provided for procedural fairness the UN would have had little to complain of. Another way of looking at it is that no judicial system worth its salt charges and convicts a group. Each person must be shown that he/she was individually responsible for the crime.
No judge in any civilized country would handle a capital crime in such a summary and bulk justice way but judges in Egypt have, over the past 3 years, been prepared to proceed in an unjudicial and pro-government way in the Mubarak cases, including others charged of financial crimes, and, more recently the lenient penalties, 7 years, for police murder of 37 protesters.
There is mounting evidence that the Egyptian Judiciary is an arm of government just as it was for decades under Sadat and Mubarak but what is new is that it thinks it can get away with scandalous breaches of due process. In the 'good old days' they would have run the case for a few months and acquitted the young and very old and the west would have said little.
In this case several hours of court hearings have been considered sufficient for 529 death sentences. Life is obviously cheap and guilt is universally uniform across this very large group.
In another case, which includes the Australian journalist, western reporters allege that the state case was not ready and that the judge had to assist state 'witnesses' because the whole case was badly investigated and presented in court. Quick and dirty court proceedings like the case of the 529 have the effect of concealing the weakness of the state case just and even with very prominent cases, such as the Jazeera Australian case, there is a shamelessness about lack of evidence and intervention by the judge to assist the state case. If they can't develop a case in this one then god knows what cases they bring to court in less prominent ones.
The Government are moving to deal with the overwhelming negative international reaction and one release emphasizes that the convictions were made by a junior and provincial court and that there was a right of appeal. Expect a suitably lengthy appear and 20% acquittals or non-capital convictions to make it look like there has been
-
- Similar Topics
- Replies
- Views
- Last post
-
- 2 Replies
- 4572 Views
-
Last post by crewmeal
-
- 8 Replies
- 3372 Views
-
Last post by Major Thom
-
- 0 Replies
- 1688 Views
-
Last post by DJKeefy
-
- 0 Replies
- 982 Views
-
Last post by DJKeefy
-
- 6 Replies
- 3210 Views
-
Last post by Glyphdoctor